Tuesday, September 3, 2013

Prototype #3: First Machining

Our last two prototypes (#1 and #2) were made by myself to simply reduce the cost and time involved. Now that our design is more refined we can make our next prototype from a machine shop (i.e., from someone who actually knows how to machine metal correctly) hopefully in preparation for an actual production run. 

For manufacturing I used a local CNC machine shop in Mississauga that I regularly used at my previous job which does great work although it is typically a little more expensive than other shops. For a material we will use Aluminum 7075-T6 which has a yield strength of around 65,000 psi. We will make two units of the same design: one for destructive testing and one we can keep. The price for making just two units was very high at around $250 per unit for just the machining costs although this is reduced to around $50/unit if the quantity is increased to 100. For the USB flash drive I just purchased some off-the-shelf consumer models and removed the plastic case. At around $350 total per unit these are definitely one of the more expensive USB drives out there.

The end result can be seen in the pictures below and it looks great! Note that the following pictures were taken after the drive spent a year in my pocket so it is a bit scratched up. The most notable design change from the previous prototypes is the addition of the engraved logo and serial number which turned out well. Our previous issue of a crooked cap on the first two prototypes has disappeared: the cap fits perfectly indicating that the issue was indeed the manual tapping process or my machining inexperience. The only notable issue was the knurling (the diamond grid pattern for grip) was a bit coarser than what I wanted at 0.08" pitch instead of 0.05".



For now only pressure testing has been performed and we again achieved success the first time at 3000 psi for one hour. A variety of destructive testing including temperature, shock, and force will be performed on one of the units later on.

This prototype was made in the fall of 2012 and one of the units has been in my pocket ever since then and has seen a lot of use. Much like the second prototype there were no usability issues noted and it looks and works like a charm.


Thursday, August 29, 2013

The Toughest USB Drive in the World

I was thinking last night while I was trying to fall asleep about the following question:

What do I need to do to honestly be able to call the VIUD the world's toughest USB drive?

While I think we're already pretty close to this point we'll look at a few areas that a USB drive needs to excel at to be called "tough":

  1. Pressure
  2. Temperature
  3. Acceleration / Shock
  4. Force / Load

The pressure rating is an immediate win for our VIUD: currently rated at 3000 psi it is at least ten times higher than any other USB drive out there except for the old Tyukalov which was rated at 2000 psi.

So far we haven't done any temperature tests except the failed 2 minutes at 1100 °C propane torch test on prototype #1. Most USB drives don't have explicit temperature ratings or they are simply set incredibly low but the LaCie Xtremkey is rated for 3 minutes at 200 °C and 30 seconds fire exposure. I hope I can beat both these ratings despite using essentially off-the-shelf USB drives since the failure mechanism is the plastic in the USB connector melting.

Most drives are also not rated for shock/acceleration with the Xtremkey again topping the chart with a rating of 50G. I haven't done any shock testing yet although the high-speed camera has been ordered and some basic calculations seem to indicate that a 50G rating should be easily beaten.

The force/load tests are really the most important ones for a "tough" USB drive and there are actually no drives out there with explicit force or load ratings. There are a few with unofficial "car/SUV drive over rating" but this is actually a relatively low bar to pass. Even a large moving truck driving over a USB only exerts around 2 tons of force which even our low strength brass prototype could withstand. Stress modelling of our Aluminum and Titanium VIUD design shows a worst case failure in end-to-end stress to be in the area of 8-10 tons. This would seem to point towards a win this category although actual destructive stress testing of competing drives will have to be done to be sure.

So while the prospecst look very good that we will be able to call our VIUD the "world's toughest USB drive" we have a bunch of testing to do first.



Monday, August 26, 2013

Prototype #2

VIUD Prototype #2
I learned a lot from making, and subsequently destroying, our first VIUD prototype and we'll quickly jump to making a second one. This prototype will essentially be the same design as the first one but be made of 6063 Aluminum instead of Brass. In this case I choose a cheaper Aluminum merely for convenience but we will likely not want to use 6063 in the end as it is one of the weaker alloys.

Machining will again be done by myself with a few tricks learned from the first prototype. The process went well although I did have issues with the cap not lining up perfectly with the body when closed despite trying to be very careful when tapping the threads. I believe the issue here is merely due to the inherent inaccuracies of manual tapping. 

Despite a slightly crooked cap pressure testing at 3000 psi for 1 hour passed the first time without any leakage. There is little point in destructive stress testing this prototype as we won't be using the same type of Aluminum in the final design, and it should be same strength as the Brass prototype anyways.

One notable observation is that this prototype is significantly lighter than the first one weighing in at only 60 g despite using a Brass thread plug. This is much nicer than the 150 g of the Brass prototype and while it is heavier than most consumer level USB drives you see it is light enough to not really notice it in your pocket, at least no where near enough to be annoying.

Prototype #2 With the Cap Off

I should note that while I am writing this blog entry in the summer of 2013 I actually made this prototype nearly a year ago in the fall of 2012. Since then this prototype has been in my pocket or backpack almost everywhere I go. After using it some hundreds of times I can't really find any fault in the design other than it not fitting some closely spaced USB connections with other things plugged into them. Its convenient, works well, nothing has broken or worn noticeably, it is relatively pretty despite my limited machining skills, and it has turned a few heads from co-workers and friends (always a good sign)!

Thursday, August 22, 2013

The First Prototype

Now that we've done our basic design and research for our rugged USB drive it's time to start making something! I'm a very amateur machinist and the basic design for the drive case is simple enough for me to attempt to make, at least for the testing prototypes. 

I choose Brass for the first prototype's material for a number of reasons: 


Brass Pros
  • Easy to machine
  • Cheap
  • Shiny!
Brass Cons
  • Mechanically Weak
  • Heavy


This is fine for a simple prototype but the Brass cons are more than enough to consider other materials for the final product (materials are to be discussed in a future blog entry).

The design of the VIUD case is relatively simple and is composed of three parts:

  1. Cap - Removable part that covers the USB connector and attached with thread.
  2. Base - Main body of the USB 
  3. Plug - Threaded plug which the USB fits into and is permanently mounted into the base.
Basic Components of our VIUD Design

Machining these parts is relatively simple, even for an amateur, although there are a few "gotchas" to note:
  • Using a tap to manually create the threads is difficult at best. You have to tap before machining the case OD or else the body walls buckle outwards. 
  • It is difficult/impossible to create a perfectly straight thread with manually tapping (even with a jig) which causes the cap to not sit perfectly on the body. This can be corrected by filing the edge of the cap but is tedious. 
  • The hole in the plug for the USB connector is machined with round corners and needs to be filed out square.
  • The groove in the plug for the main o-ring seal was done after assembly and the epoxy had hardened to ensure a perfect fit.
  • The mount for the cap at the end of the base was added afterwards by press fitting an additional piece into the base.
For the USB flash drive itself I merely purchased a cheap 2GB consumer level drive and removed the plastic case. Assembly merely required to insert the USB into the rear side of the plug, fill the base with epoxy (enough to squeeze out when assembled) and screw the plug into the base. After letting the epoxy dry and machining a groove for the o-ring seal in the plug the first prototype VIUD is finished! Unfortunately I don't have any pictures of the prototype before its destruction in stress testing.

Testing

End-to-End Stress Modelling
Our first VIUD prototype may not look too pretty but it is fine for basic testing of our design. First is a simple handling test: How does the drive feel in terms of weight and size. The size feels fine although it is significantly larger than most USB flash drives these days. It is a little on the heavy side, however, at around 150 g. Not terrible but a little too noticeable when held in your pocket. The overall physical operation of the drive is also fine and doesn't reveal any unforeseen difficulties.

Next, with our simple and cheap pressure testing rig we can easily see what pressure our prototype can handle. Fortunately, even with a slightly crooked cap it successfully passed a 1 hour test at 3000 psi with no leaks! 

Temperature testing was next and I was evidently a little too eager at this stage by using a propane blow torch. Even with just a 2 minute external exposure of 1100 °C the plastic in the USB connector melted completely and a quick repair attempt failed to get the USB drive to respond when plugged in to a computer.

Since the drive was already toast the next and final test was the destructive stress test. I purchased a basic 10 ton hydraulic press from my favourite store Princess Auto. I had done some basic stress modelling using Solidworks and Autocad Inventor which showed the failure of the Brass prototype should occur at around 4000-5000 lbs on the threads of the cap with a vertical load. The modelling proved very accurate as that is exactly when and where the prototype failed! We usually assume modelling is reasonably accurate but it is always nice to see it verified once and a while.

Brass VIUD Prototype #1 -- After Destructive Testing

Lessons Learned

Despite the first prototype being destroyed during testing it yielded a number of important insights:
  • Validated the overall design.
  • Handling pressures up to 3000 psi should be no issue.
  • Brass is too heavy and too soft a material for a true VIUD.
  • Manually trying to tap the threads myself doesn't work very well.
  • The mechanical stress modelling agrees very well with the actual stress testing.
  • Temperature testing will have to be done a little more carefully (no propane torch)!
More prototypes, testing and research await for us on our quest for the ultimate VIUD....


Monday, August 19, 2013

High Pressure Testing on the Cheap

One the primary design requirements for the rugged USB drive is a high pressure rating: at least 1000 psi if not considerably higher. In order to test our design to see if it actually works we'll need a pressure testing rig. Creating a completely custom pressure testing rig is not necessarily difficult but even a small one would end up being $1000s in design and manufacturing costs. It would be nice to be able to create a very simple rig consisting of cheaper off-the-shelf components.

Looking at industrial product sites like McMaster or Acklands-Grainger we find that the highest pressure rating easily obtainable are 3000 psi which should be more than sufficient for our purposes and are relatively cheap. For now the desired volume of the rig can be kept low: just enough for 1 or 2 USB cases at a time.

For pressurization of the vessel normally some sort of pump would be used but in order to keep the design simple and costs as low as possible we'll just use a piston which can be pushed into the vessel. Since the vessel volume is small we can use a rod with a small cross-section (0.5in diameter) and thus keep the force required to push it in low (< 100 kgs) as well as the distance it needs to be pushed in (about 2in for 3000psi for this vessel).
The overall design of the pressure vessel can be seen below using off-the-shelf 2in NPT iron pipe fittings rated at 3000 psi. Its overall height is just under 1 ft and its total weight is around 35 lbs due to the heavy duty iron fittings. We some effort we could probably fit 4-6 USB cases inside it at a time.
Overall Pressure Vessel Design
The details for the pressurization lid and rod can be seen below. We use two hydraulic o-ring lip seals which are rated to 3000 psi each and result in no leakage when the rod is pushed in or out.  
Detail of the Pressurization Rod
The final material cost for this pressure testing rig ended up being less than $100 which is surprisingly low. The assembly of the rig was very simple and other than screwing together the pipe fittings it only required a simple machining of the end cap for the lip seals. Use of the rig is relatively straightforward:

  1. Remove cap.
  2. Add object to be tested.
  3. Fill vessel with water.
  4. Replace cap ensuring pressurization rod is extended.
  5. Push the pressurization rod into the vessel to achieve the desired pressure. I created a simple clamp using two threaded rods and some Aluminum plates which cannot slip off the rod.
  6. Wait for a set period of time, typically one hour.
  7. De-pressurize vessel, remove object and check for failures.


More features could be easily added to this design depending on the budget and desired requirements. A few things I can think of being needed in the near future for our purposes:
  • Ball or gate valve to more easily put objects inside the vessel (costly for a 3000 psi version).
  • Larger volume for testing more USB drives at once. This may also require the diameter of the pressurization rod to be increased.
  • Change to a hand pump for pressurization. This would be required if the vessel volume is considerably increased.

Now that we've got a pressure test rig we can get on to creating and testing some VIUD prototypes!

Monday, March 11, 2013

Looking at the Competition

Looking at existing products in the rugged, waterproof or otherwise indestructible USB drive market is useful for a few reasons:
  1. It may be that our "best" VIUD already exists.
  2. Compare and possible change our design with what is available.
  3. Get a better idea of prices if we wish to market our drive.
The following are a selection of better products found from searches of rugged, waterproof or indestructible USB drives.

Corsair Survivor

The Corsair Survivor looks like a relatively nice consumer level rugged and waterproof USB drive. It has a nice waterproof rating of 300 psi and its Aluminum case looks like it would take a pretty good beating. The design, in my opinion, is not ideal with a very large cap which may be easily lost. It has a relatively low price range of $30-85.

LaCie XtremKey  

The LaCie XtremKey looks like a decent candidate for a VIUD with a 300 psi waterproof and to a 10 ton pressure resistant rating. The "resistant" qualifier is suspect but with an all metal case it looks like it could handle being run over by a large car depending on the exact type of metal used (they mention a Zamac alloy but not which one). It has a large cap design like the Survivor which I dislike. Its price point is slightly higher at $85-140 but is not unreasonable for such a rugged device.

One notable specification for this drive is its large range of temperatures, particularly its high temperature limit of 200 °C. Although they again say "resistant" this is much higher than any other USB drive I've seen that actually has any temperature ratings (most don't).

Imation Ironkey Basic

The Ironkey Basic from Imation is a very nice looking drive with what looks like a basic metal case which would protect it from everyday bumps and drops but probably not larger accidents. It is rated waterproof under specification MIL-STD-810 which, as far as I can tell, is close to IP67/68 or essentially just waterproof from basic immersion and not pressure rated.

The drive's price is significantly higher than other rugged drives at $90-300 despite being less rugged. This is likely due to the Ironkey's main purpose of being an encrypted drive. Overall a great looking drive but not exactly what we're looking for our own VIUD. In theory if we wanted encryption it could be done at the software level.

Tyukalov USB Drive

The Tyukalov drive is a unique, one of a kind, custom USB drive which is interesting to compare to the consumer type drives previously found. It was made in a limited quantity of 100 at a relatively high price of $200-250 each but managed to sell out in a short period of 3 weeks. Its unique dual cavity design is not particularly convenient but it boosts the highest waterproof rating of 2000 psi of any USB drive I've seen and undoubtedly an equally high rugged rating.

Eternal Case

The Eternal Case is a product that wasn't out when I initially researched and came up with my VIUD design in the fall of 2012 but is remarkably similar. It just goes to show that if you think of a good idea there's a good chance someone else already has or soon will.

There are no explicit ratings for this custom product but from its design I would guess it should be waterproof to at least 300 psi and would easily withstand being run over by a car. Its price is amazingly low at only $40-75, even for a 32GB Titanium model. Based on what I've researched for prices I'm unsure how they can make a profit at this price. The only negative thing I can see is that the design/manufacture is relatively rough looking.

Wrapping Up...

There are other drives that are marketed as "rugged" but the majority don't actually have an explicit mechanical or waterproof specification. Most appear to be just cheap drives surrounded by a thin metal case with a "rugged" label which is not what I'm looking for my own VIUD. 

Even with this relatively small collection of existing true rugged drives it gives us a relatively good baseline on what is currently available and at what price. It also helps narrow down some of our design constraints, or at least what we would like them to be:

  • >2000 psi waterproof rating
  • >10 ton crush rating
  • >200°C for 3 minutes temperature rating
  • $40-300 (depends on capacity, quality, and ultimate rating)

Time will tell whether any of these are actually possible or not....


Thursday, March 7, 2013

Design Details for the VIUD

I listed my mostly arbitrary "design requirements" for my virtually indestructible USB drive in the first blog post and would like to explore and explain them in more details.

Waterproof

Having our drive be waterproof is a relatively obvious requirement even though USB disks tend to be relatively impervious to water just by themselves. If a cheaper drive gets wet it is generally just a matter of drying it out before using it again. The key word there, of course, is "generally". If you try to use a wet USB drive, get it wet with impure water which may cause deposits to form on the circuit board when the water evaporates, or even drop it in something other than water then your drive may not fare so well. I would like a drive so waterproof there would be no worry about getting it wet or dirty.

The other question in regards to waterproof is "how waterproof"?  It is easy to mistake this for a binary "yes/no" question when in fact there are a number of standards such as IP and NEMA made to determine how water (and dust) proof an item really is. But even these are just the beginning: the highest typical IP rating is IP68 which only represents something being able to withstand continuous immersion in 1 m of water. Waterproof ratings beyond this are typically specified in how much pressure something can withstand over a certain period of time.

A quick calculation shows that for every 1 m underwater our pressure increases by 1.5 psi (10 kPa). In my previous job we would regularly make parts that were rated to at least 300 psi for use in water systems and other parts rated to 3000 psi for use in oil and gas, each typically rated at that pressure for at least several hours with no leaks. Exactly how high of a rating we need, or want, for our own USB drive depends mostly on how difficult it will be to achieve although ideally we'd like a pressure rating as high as possible.


Crush Resistant/Rugged

This is a particularly weak point of most USB drives out there. Cheap ones likely wouldn't survive being stepped on and even most metal cased ones wouldn't survive being run over by a car.  In order to meet its namesake of a "virtually indestructible" drive we'd like our design to be as strong as possible without having to sacrifice any of its other requirements, especially its price. Ideally something that would just shrug off being run over by a large car or truck would be great.


Prevent Cap Loss

I simply can't stand USB drives that have a detachable cap with no method of storing it. Generally these caps only last around 27 seconds before they are lost in some unexplainable manner. In order to meet the "rugged" and "waterproof" requirements we will almost assuredly need a cap and so will also need a design to prevent the cap from being easily lost.


Price

Making a VIUD would be relatively easy if price were no object. If we were just making a one of a kind drive then price would be mostly irrelevant but if we wish to market and sell these drives at some point (a fair assumption) then having something more affordable would be advantageous.

The price per drive can be roughly broken up into three categories:

  1. Case Manufacturing - Mass production can greatly decrease the price per unit.
  2. USB Drive Board - Buying something off the shelf in bulk would be ideal.
  3. Assembly - Something that minimizes the final assembly time would be good.
There is also the one time development costs, marketing, shipping, and hours spent on the project to consider to ensure that we don't lose money by making the drives.



Shiny!

This may appear to be a silly design requirement but making a good looking, or even beautiful, drive is important, particularly if we're interested in selling it is as a product.

Convenient

I forgot about this design requirement initially although it may be one of the more important. We could easily make an indestructible USB drive by encasing it in a 10 kg brick of Titanium. This would more than satisfy all design requirements, except possibly the price, jowever, a 10 kg brick is not something you can drop in your pocket and use anywhere you would use a regular USB drive. Ideally we would want something very similar in size, shape, and weight to existing USB drives, or at least not too far away from.


So it seems our design requirements are complete even if some of them are in the "as rugged as possible" category. It will take some design testing and prototypes to determine exactly how much we can get.